Help

So found two possible cars and the wife and a can’t decide. We had said we wanted a manual. If it’s small it has to be fun. But turns out mini JCW with a stick is super rare (Seems dumb)

And even the S isn’t easy to find. Given up on a club man. Can’t find one.

Two possable

One 2016 5 door cooper S
77000km. Light blue with black roof and mirrors. Pretty much loaded and has the manual. But it’s got a few small dings and scratches.

Other is a 2015 Cooper S. 45000km red and black
Also loaded including the JCW package (bumpers spoiler etc)
But it’s an auto.
Pretty much flawless no dents or dings to be seen.

The 15 is more money up front but has a better interest rate so payments are pretty much identical

So auto and wicked looking or plain looking and manual